I discovered Glynx some time ago. The concept is interesting but there are some "unresolved" questions. This drives me to try to collect here some background info then some wishes.
This area of online identity management is not really well defined. And it touch to other key aspects like reputation, identification, security ... So, you may think that some items are missing and others are not relevant.
Online identity and Social graph
We leave bits and pieces of our identity on various locations online. For example, creating a mail account on Gmail is creating a bit of our identity. For the people we send mail to, we will be known as jean.dupont@gmail.com. The Gmail service will store our mails and also the mail address of our correspondents. This is the start of an online identity and also of a social graph. The same apply to other services like Flickr, FaceBook, FriendFeed, Twitter ...
Soon, there are three big needs appearing.
The need to manage our identity
We need to keep track of the various online services we opened an account on, the information we disclosed on each services and who can see this information. It would be better if we could keep most of this information locally on our computer and give to each piece of information some group permission like "Family", "Business contact", "Unknown visitors"
The need to own and manage our social graph
Our identity is the most valuable thing we have online. Our social graph is an important part of our identity[1]. It is also a tool for other people to know us. This graph being scattered on so many services, it is difficult if not impossible to properly manage it.
The need for trust and credential
When we connect to somebody, we need to be able to trust that the online identity we connect to is owned by the people we know wether we know this people by another online identity or by his/her offline identity.
A tool to manage our online identity
We need to "own" the data. This means that we either manage it locally through a tool we can trust, or we delegate it handling and storage to a service we can trust. I recently discovered Glynx. The presentation is interesting, the tool has already some real value inside even if it is not yet polished on the outside.
Just a note on the software itself. I will not be critical on it. This is not the purpose of this note. Glynx is based on open source software even if it license is clearly closed source. The user interface is really average. To have some real adoption, it will need to be more polished. This is not an issue in the mean time if the services it provide are of real value to users.
Taking opportunity of the availability of this tool, let's discuss what is missing.
The need for critical mass adoption for it to be useful
Glynx uses "BlackPage" to allow to establish peer to peer connection. BlackPages are like White pages but opaque in order to protect privacy.
The first to go for this kind of tools will be geeks. But these people wants to know a lot more before adopting such a product. They will ask a lot of questions about security, trust and so on. So they will prefer to go with an open source[2] tool because of the possibility to scrutinize it. There are initiatives in the open source which does not seem to have much success. A closed source one has few chances to convince.
Then, going to more mainstream users, I will have a hard time to convince my "average" contacts to install another app to handle their identity before they see any real benefit (see services) for them apart from "being master of my contacts...".
The number of sources and social networks it can scan
On the local machine, it should get the list of IM contacts, and the content of the address book not only on Outlook but also on Thunderbird at least. There is a Vcard import feature, but it is not for the casual user. And a quick test exporting a vcard from Entourage and trying to import it to Glynx, did not gave a result.
The "power users" are not only on FaceBook, they are on LinkedIn, Orkut, Plaxo, FriendFeed, Viaduc, Xing, Flickr...
And the issue is to reconcile the various connections they have or they forgot to create on some of these networks.
The services it can provide
The main service is clear for some people which are concerned about their digital identity. But the average user need more incentive to switch to using "yet another application". So giving this product some additional related features would help adoption :
- Password manager (this seems a logical connection).
- Address book synch between Gmail, phone and local address book...
If this software is willing to go to the professional market, it should connect to LDAP.
See also
As far as I know, there are no equivalent software availalble in this field. But there are some online services claiming to allow you to have all your online personal data in one place (see also resources at end). This is called social network aggregators.
Some initiatives
Open source Social networks, norms, protocols and API
Lot of services are becoming OpentID provider. That is good for spreading OpenID. But it is useless for the broader issue.
Identity
Software and services
As far as I know, there is nothing really avaiable in this area...
A partial list of sytems where you give your data
Some bibliographical ressources
See also here
Identity
Social graph